April 20th, 2011 – NISA requested NRC information regarding legal issues related to TMI

Author: No Comments Share:

From:Wittick, Brian
Sent:Wednesday, April 20, 2011 7:29 PM
To:Casto, Chuck
Cc:Reynolds, Steven
Subject:FW: NISA Request
Attachments:50-54(x)&(y)48FR1 3966.pdf

FYI – HQ has provided NISA answers to part of their questions (the legal piece) regarding TMI, and remains inactive dialogue through the normal IP cooperation channels.



From: Bloom, Steven
Sent: Wednesday, April 20, 2011 8:04 AM
To: bannai-toshihirowmeti.go.jp
Cc: Foggie, Kirk; Emche, Danielle
Subject: NISA Request

Dear Bannai-san,

Below is the response I have gotten from our legal staff regarding your request on legal issues related to TMI:
Strictly speaking, as far as we know, the NRC did not take any action by rule which would deem legal and justified any responsive action taken by the TMI licensee at the time of and immediately following the 1979 accident.

However, the NRC did adopt new regulations in 10 CFR 50.54(x) and (y) to ensure that licensees would be able to take timely and necessary action even though such action would be in violation of the plant’s technical specifications, license conditions or other regulatory requirements. The final rule for these provisions is 48 FR 13966 (April 1, 1983). A copy of the SOC for the final rule is attached. Our legal view is that this regulation may be applied only when the licensee action is needed to avoid imminent radiological harm the general public, i.e., in quickly emerging situations where fast action is needed to avoid radiological harm to the general public. The staff’s practice has been more lenient, however, despite OGC’s interpretation.

If you have any questions, please let me know.

Thank you,

Steven Bloom, International Relations Specialist
International Cooperation and Assistance Branch (ICA)
M/S 0-4E21

NRC Transmission to METI – Request on Legal Issues Related to TMI

Previous Article

March 25th, 2011 – Probability of Containment Failure – NUREG/CR 6920 – 1150

Next Article

March 16th, 2011 – Might consider completing a worse case dose map